top of page

Is Your Token a Security? ChatGPT's AI-Powered Legal Opinion for New Social Media

new social media

Facing the crucial question of whether our token of new social media platform is a security, our team sought answers from ChatGPT, an advanced AI language model. Knowing that a clear answer would be the key to listing our token on most crypto exchanges, we delved into the AI's in-depth analysis of the token's utility, functionality, distribution, and governance structure, along with the application of the renowned Howey Test. Get ready to explore the AI's compelling conclusion and its impact on our Challenge app ecosystem, as well as our journey towards listing on crypto exchanges.

This legal opinion will analyze whether the CHL token, as described in the provided tokenomics, should be considered a security under applicable law. Based on the key factors examined in this analysis, including the utility and functionality of the token, as well as its distribution and governance structure, we conclude that the CHL token primarily represents a utility feature and is not a security.

The CHL token is associated with the Challenge app, a platform designed to encourage users to set and achieve personal goals through the use of challenges. The tokenomics provided outline the distribution, utility, and value of the CHL token, as well as mechanisms for maintaining its stability.

Legal Framework

The primary legal framework for determining whether a token is a security is the Howey Test, which was established by the U.S. Supreme Court in SEC v. W.J. Howey Co. (328 U.S. 293, 1946). According to the Howey Test, an investment contract (i.e., a security) exists when:

  1. There is an investment of money;

  2. In a common enterprise;

  3. With an expectation of profits;

  4. Derived solely from the efforts of others.

Additionally, the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has released guidance on the application of the Howey Test to digital assets, which considers factors such as the rights and expectations of token holders, as well as the nature and purpose of the token within its ecosystem.

IV. Analysis

A. Utility and Functionality of the Token

The CHL token serves multiple purposes within the Challenge app ecosystem. It functions as a reward for users who complete challenges, allows users to unlock premium features, enables participation in exclusive challenges, and serves as a means to enhance user accounts. Furthermore, CHL tokens can be used to pay for goods and services on partnering platforms and to purchase NFTs related to challenges. These various utilities indicate that the primary purpose of the CHL token is to facilitate and enhance user engagement within the Challenge app, rather than serving as an investment vehicle.

B. Distribution and Governance Structure

The token distribution is as follows:

  • 40% allocated for user rewards

  • 25% allocated for development and operations

  • 20% allocated for marketing and partnerships

  • 10% allocated for founders and early investors

  • 5% allocated for advisors and future team members

This distribution structure supports the development and growth of the platform and its user base, rather than primarily benefitting investors or founders.

C. Application of the Howey Test

  1. Investment of Money: Although users may acquire CHL tokens by investing money, the primary method of obtaining tokens is through active participation on the platform by completing challenges or engaging with the platform in other ways.

  2. Common Enterprise: While the success of the platform and the token's value are closely linked, the token's primary purpose is its utility within the Challenge app ecosystem, rather than generating profits for token holders.

  3. Expectation of Profits: The CHL token is designed to be used within the platform and to facilitate user engagement. Although the token's value may increase as demand grows, the primary motivation for holding CHL tokens is to use them within the app, rather than to realize profits through passive appreciation.

  4. Efforts of Others: Users earn tokens through their own efforts by completing challenges and engaging with the platform. Although the platform's management and development team play a role in maintaining the token's value and stability, the value of the token is largely influenced by market demand and supply, driven by the collective actions of the platform's users. Conclusion Based on the analysis of the CHL token, including its utility and functionality, as well as its distribution and governance structure, we conclude that the CHL token primarily represents a utility feature and is not a security. The CHL token's main purpose is to facilitate and enhance user engagement within the Challenge app, rather than serving as an investment vehicle.

While certain aspects of the Howey Test are present in the CHL token, the emphasis on its utility and the active role of users in obtaining tokens through their own efforts within the platform suggest that it does not meet the criteria for classification as a security.

It is recommended that the Challenge app maintain a focus on the utility aspects of the CHL token and continue to engage in dialogue with legal counsel and, if necessary, the SEC to ensure compliance with securities laws and reduce the risk of regulatory enforcement actions in the future. Stay tuned for our next article, where we'll be sharing our story of how the Challenge Team is building our own app from scratch. Learn from our experiences and gain insights on how to take your own app from idea to launch. Get inspired and motivated to start building the next big thing in social media! To ensure you don't miss out, subscribe to our social media content and be the first to know when the article drops! Don't wait, subscribe now and stay ahead of the game.

Recent Posts

See All


bottom of page